How to Choose an
Engagement Ring

Everything you need to know, from ring style and diamond shape to the 4Cs and setting a budget. A private guide from Nathan Alan Jewelers, Newport Beach.

Where to Begin

Getting It Right

You've decided it's time to propose. Congratulations. Now all you need to do is purchase the ring of their dreams. Everything might seem easy until you find yourself navigating one of the most important purchases of your life. These are the questions that will guide you along the journey.

An engagement ring is the only purchase in your lifetime that your partner will admire every day, a reminder of how special you and your relationship are. It is the most important symbol of your love and commitment, one they will cherish for the rest of their life. Honing in on an overall style is a helpful place to begin.

Eight Questions to Ask Before You Begin

  • What kind of ring style are they considering?
  • What type of metal?
  • What shape for the center stone?
  • What quality? The 4Cs: Cut, Color, Clarity, Carat Weight
  • What is their finger size?
  • How much should I spend?
  • Should I bring them or keep it a surprise?
  • Where should I buy the ring?

The Five Classic Styles

Engagement Ring Styles

Most engagement rings fall into one of five foundational styles. Understanding each one will help you narrow your search considerably. All five are available at Nathan Alan Jewelers with natural or lab-grown diamonds.

Halo

Beauty and grace. A single stone surrounded by many smaller stones, framing the shape and beauty of the center stone. The overall effect is that of a larger center stone. The halo holds the center stone securely in place and helps protect it.

View Halo Rings →

Solitaire

Iconic. The most classic. A single stone set above the band on the metal of your choice with no accents. The focus is center stage on the diamond or gemstone you select. Sometimes referred to as a classic solitaire, four or six prong solitaire, or single stone solitaire.

View Solitaires →

Side Stone

Elegant accents. Small diamonds are set into the metal enhancing the center stone. Smaller diamonds add beauty and sparkle to the ring. Typically the diamond side stones are pavé set or micro pavé set, shared prong set, or channel set on the band.

View Side Stone Rings →

Three Stone

Timeless and elegant. The center stone accented by one stone on each of its sides. The center stone is typically larger than the two side stones. Either all three are the same shape or the two sides can be different shapes from the center. A three stone ring is symbolic of the past, present, and future.

View Three Stone Rings →

Vintage

Delicate and feminine. A vintage ring can be made in variations of the other styles but accompanied with milgrain beading, decorative engraving, or beautiful scroll-work known as filigree. Vintage designs are often referred to as antique, art deco, or estate jewelry.

View Vintage Rings →

Custom Design

Create your own custom one of a kind engagement ring that will be a beautiful representation of the love you are celebrating. Select a jeweler with top quality craftsmen and an experienced team skilled at design, fabrication and hand setting. Any ring can be made exactly to your very own specifications.

Start a Custom Design →

The Setting

Choosing the Right Metal

The metal you choose affects the look, feel, and durability of the ring over a lifetime of wear. Both options we work with are exceptional. The right choice comes down to personal preference.

Gold

Gold is available in three colors: white, yellow, and rose. 18 karat gold is the most common and exclusively used by luxury jewelers. Gold is shiny, durable, and can withstand the test of time.

Platinum

Platinum is a pure white metal, 30 times more rare than gold and twice as dense as gold. The feel of platinum and its natural white color is generally what attracts consumers to buy it. It also can withstand the test of time. You cannot choose the wrong metal , both are excellent choices.

Diamond Quality

Understanding the 4Cs

The 4Cs are the universal grading system for diamond quality, established by the Gemological Institute of America. Understanding them helps you make an informed decision and prioritize what matters most for your budget.

The Most Important C

Cut

100% of the diamond's brilliance, fire and sparkle are a direct reflection of the diamond's overall cut quality, proportions, ratio, and symmetry. Find a jeweler with a deep understanding of how the 4Cs affect a diamond's overall value, appearance, and respect your budget. A great jeweler will provide you with the best diamond options factoring in what is most important to you.

Second Priority

Color

A diamond's color is graded D-Z. D, E, and F are the highest grades and are considered colorless. G, H, I, and J are in the near colorless range. K, L, and M are faint yellow. N-R very light yellow and S-Z light yellow.

Often Overrated

Clarity

Nearly every diamond has physical characteristics known as inclusions or imperfections. Diamonds are rated from Internally Flawless to Imperfect. The fewer inclusions a diamond has, the rarer the diamond is.

Size and Weight

Carat

Simply stated, carat weight is how much a diamond weighs on a scale. There are endless combinations of all 4Cs available. The overall combination you choose will determine the cost, which is the 5th and final C.

The Center Stone

Diamond Shapes

The shape of the center stone is one of the most visible and personal choices in the entire process. Each shape has its own character, light performance, and proportion on the hand. We carry and can source every shape in both natural and lab-grown diamonds.

Common Questions

What Most Clients Ask Us

How much should I spend on an engagement ring?+
Forget everything you have heard about budget. There is no standard. Each individual should evaluate their maximum amount to spend on an engagement ring. There are no fixed rules. Approach price with an open mind and learn how quality can affect price. Once you have met the jeweler who is honest, knowledgeable and able to sell you any diamond, share with them your max budget and allow them to help you make the best selection for your partner. Remember, the best diamond is the diamond that you choose, that fits both the price you are willing to pay and matches the quality and style your partner deeply desires.
Should I bring my partner to choose the ring, or keep it a surprise?+
This is completely subjective. Just remember bringing your loved one along on the search will really help you to focus on style. You can still have the element of surprise by proposing at a completely random or planned time. Let your loved one show you what they like, because sometimes what they see in pictures versus what they actually try on may change their opinion. A little pre-shopping will just solidify the style. Again, there are no rules here. A complete surprise can be amazing too!
Should I choose a lab-grown or natural diamond?+
Both are real diamonds. The difference is origin and price. Lab-grown diamonds are chemically and visually identical to mined diamonds and cost significantly less for the same quality. Natural diamonds have a longer resale history and some clients feel strongly about the romance of a stone formed over billions of years. We carry both and can show them side by side during your consultation. Read our full lab vs. natural comparison for more detail.
Where is the best place to buy an engagement ring?+
A reputable jeweler should demonstrate vast experience, knowledge, selection and exceptional craftsmanship. Work with a jeweler who can provide you with all of the appropriate certifications for the diamonds or gemstones you choose. Expect a quality jeweler to guide you and help you make the best selection for you and your fiancé. Call Nathan Alan Jewelers at (714) 545-8337 , we have served Southern California clients since 1980.
How do I find out their ring size without them knowing?+
It is always ideal to have your significant other's finger sized by the jeweler you are going to buy the ring from. There are a few tricks: find a ring that you know fits and bring it with you to your jeweler. If you are worried about this, perhaps you can trace a ring inside and out on a piece of paper to bring with you. You may also be able to get the ring size from a friend or relative. Most rings can be sized after the proposal as well.
Can I design a fully custom engagement ring?+
Yes, and it is one of our specialties. We work with clients to design engagement rings from concept to completion, selecting the stone, designing the setting, choosing the metal, and hand-finishing every detail. Custom work typically takes four to six weeks. Learn more about our custom design process.

Ready to Find the Perfect Ring?

Book a private consultation in Newport Beach. We will walk you through every option, answer every question, and help you find the ring they have always imagined.

Nathan Alan Jewelers
Our Story Contact Book Consultation